Menu

Our Menu.



COLD STARTERS

  Smoked Fish Dip $14

Sesame Flatbread Crackers, Capers & Pickled Jalapeno Slices

  Caribbbean Guac & Chips Caribbbean Guac & Chips is a Gluten-Free Item$14

Avocado-Papaya-Mango Guacamole, House Corn Tortilla Chips

  *Seared Ahi Tuna *Seared Ahi Tuna is a Gluten-Free Item$16

Ponzu Marinated, Pickled Ginger, Seaweed, Wasabi

  *Ahi Poke Tuna Tower $17

Layers of Raw Ahi Tuna, Seaweed, Mango-Ginger Salsa, House Wonton Chips

  Ceviche $16

Fresh Local Yellowtail, Keys Style Marinade, Coconut Milk, House Corn Chips

HOT STARTERS

  Havana Fries Havana Fries is a Gluten-Free Item$14

Yuca Fries, Pulled Pork, Southern Comfort Onion Jam, Cheddar-Monterrey Cheese, Cilantro-Garlic-Crema

  Seafood Nachos Seafood Nachos is a Gluten-Free Item$16

Corn Chips, Shrimp, Scallops, Mahiu, Melted Cheddar, Sour Cream, Pico

  Baked Elote Baked Elote is a Gluten-Free Item$12

White Corn, Cilantro Crema, Parmesan Gratedu, Lime Pepper Seasoned

  JAMAICAN PEEL N EAT SHRIMP $17

½ lb Wild Caught Pink Shrimp, Yuengling Beer Steamed, Jamaican Seasoned

  Crispy Calamari $15

Cornmeal Dusted, Flash Fried, Orange Chili Dipping Sauce

  Lobster & Crab Dip $15

Creamy-Cheesy Spinach, Lump Crab, Lobster Meat, House Corn Tortilla Chips

  Conch Fritter Bites $14

Traditional Conch Fritters, Key Lime Mustard Sauce

Perfect Compliments
SOUPS AND SALADS

  Bahamian Conch Chowder Bahamian Conch Chowder is a Gluten-Free Item$9

Sausage, Dark Rum, Tomato-Vegetable

  Crab Bisque $9

Sherry-Cream-Blue Crab Bisque

  Loaded Rice Bowl $17

Island Rice, Pico, Elote, Broccoli, Jicama Slaw, Tomato, Sriracha Aioli, Cilantro Crema, Jack & Cheddar Cheese

  Traditional Caesar $14

Romaine, Challah Croutons, Shredded Parmesan Cheese

  ORIENTAL SALAD $16

Mixed Greens, Seaweed Salad, Crispy Wonton Strips, Sliced, Almonds, Mandarin Orange, Julienne Radish, Ponzu Vinaigrette

  Bayside Original Bayside Original is a Gluten-Free Item$15

Romaine-Spring Mix Blend, Julienne Radish, Diced Papaya, Mandarin Oranges, Grape Tomatoes, Red Cabbage, Green Goddess Dressing

  Add to Salad

Free Range Chicken +7 ~ Jumbo Shrimp +12 ~ 6oz Mahi +12 ~ Tuna +12

Two Hands Required
BAYSIDE SANDWICHES

  Bayside mahi Sandwich $19

Mozzarella, Brioche, Beer Battered Potato Curls, Lettuce, Tomato, Sliced Red Onion, Pickle Slices, Cole Slaw

  BAHAMA MAHI SANDWICH $19

Panko Breaded & Crispy Fried, Jicama-Radish Slaw, Southern Comfort Onion Jam, Mozzarella, Rocoto Aioli, Beer Battered Potato Curls & Cole Slaw

  Chorizo Burger $18

½lb Chorizo-Beef Blend, Jicama-Radish Slaw, Pico, Melted Mozzarella, Beer Battered Potato Curls, Cole Slaw

  Island Fish Tacos $21

Pico di Gallo, Jicama-Radish Slaw, Cilantro-Garlic Crema, Choose Grilled Mahi or House Roasted Pulled Pork

  *Cheesburger $16

½lb CAB ® Short Rib Beef Blend, American Cheese, Brioche, Lettuce, Tomato, Sliced Red Onion, Beer Battered Potato Curls, Pickle Slices, Cole Slaw

LITTLE MINNOWS
12 years old & under

  Grilled Cheese $8

Thick Sliced Challah Bread, Real American Cheese, French Fries

  Filet & Chips $18

* 5oz Beef Tenderloin, Open Flame Grilled, French Fries

  Chicken Fingers & Chips $12

All-Natural Chicken, Panko Hand Breaded, French Fries

  Linguini $12

Marinara Sauce or Melted Butter

BEVERAGES
Non-Alcoholic

  Soft Drinks $5

Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Sierra Mist, Ginger Ale, Tropicana, Lemonade, Orange Crush, Dr Pepper, 20oz Fountain Soda, Complimentary Refills

  Juices $5

Orange, Grapefruit, Cranberry, Pineapple, 10oz, No Refills

  Iced Tea 5

20oz, Complimentary Refills

  Panna Half Btl $5 ~ Full Btl $10

Still

  Milk $5

10oz, Whole Milk, No Refills

  Pellegrino Half Btl $5 ~ Full Btl $10

Sparkling

From The Dock
FRESH CATCH

  Baked Baked is a Gluten-Free Item

Key Lime Beurre Blanc, Krispy Kapers
Mahi 29 ~ Yellowtail 36 ~ Fresh Catch of the Day MP

  Blackened Blackened is a Gluten-Free Item

Cajun Seasoned, Mango-Ginger Salsa
Mahi 29 ~ Yellowtail 36 ~ Fresh Catch of the Day MP

  Keyribbian Style Keyribbian Style is a Gluten-Free Item

Capers, Garlic, Key Lime, White Wine, Butter Sauce
Mahi 31 ~ Yellowtail 38 ~ Fresh Catch of the Day MP

  Bayside Style

Dusted & Seared, Caper, Jalapeno, Tomato, Artichoke, White Wine Sauce
Mahi 32 ~ Yellowtail 39 ~ Fresh Catch of the Day MP

Sophisticated Keyribbean
SEAFOOD SPECIALTIES

  WHOLE FRIED SNAPPER $36

Whole Local Snapper, Crispy Fried Key Lime-Caper-Garlic-Butter Sauce & Island Rice

  KEY LARGO SAMPLER $45

½ Lobster Tail, Jumbo Shrimp, Jumbo Scallops, Mahi, Key Lime Beurre Blanc, Crispy Capers, Island Rice

  FISH TRIO FISH TRIO is a Gluten-Free Item$38

Mahi ~ Yellowtail ~ Fresh Catch of the Dayu, Key Lime Beurre Blanc, crispy capers, Island Rice

  ISLAND SEAFOOD CURRY ISLAND SEAFOOD CURRY is a Gluten-Free Item$34

Jumbo Shrimp & North Atlantic Scallops, Green Curry-Coconut Pineapple Sauce, Toasted Almonds, Island Rice

  Shrimp Jambalaya $27

Jumbo Shrimp, Andouille Sausage, Peppers, Onions, Cajun Tomato Sauce & Island Rice

  Keyribbean Shrimp $27

Corn Meal Dusted Jumbo Shrimp, Key Lime-Caper-Garlic-Butter Sauce & Island Rice

  Seafood Enchiladas $24

Corn Tortillas Stuffed with Shrimp, Scallops & Mahi, House Enchilada Sauce, Monterey & Jack Cheeses, Island Rice

Breaded, Battered, Perfection
SIMPLY FRIED SEAFOOD

  OCEAN BOUNTY BUCKET $29

Fried Shrimp, Scallop Chunks, Conch Fritters, Mahi, Dill Relish Tartar Sauce or Bloody Mary Cocktail Sauce, Beer Battered Potato Curls & Cole Slaw

  Coconut Shrimp & Chips $26

Coconut Batter-Dipped, Golden Fried, Orange Chili Dipping Sauce, Beer Battered Potato Curls & Cole Slaw

  FRIED SHRIMP & Chips $24

Jumbo Shrimp, Panko Hand Breaded, Dill Relish Tartar Sauce or Bloody Mary Cocktail Sauce, Beer Battered Potato Curls & Cole Slaw

  Fish & Chips $21

Mahi Filet, Panko Hand Breaded, Golden Fried, Dill Relish Tartar Sauce or Bloody Mary Cocktail Sauce, Beer Battered Potato Curls & Cole Slaw

Savory Meats And More
LANDLUBBERS

  *Ribeye *Ribeye is a Gluten-Free Item$39

12oz CAB ® Center Cut, Open Flame Grilled, House Rocoto Butter, Red Skin Cheddar Smashed & Vegetable Medley

  CARIBBEAN BBQ RIBS $32

Full Rack, Baby Back Ribs with Housemade, Caribbean BBQ Sauce, Red Skin Cheddar Smashed & Veggies

  *Filet Medallions $39

Twin 5oz Tenderloins, Open Flame Grilled, House Mango Chimichurri, Red Skin Cheddar Smashed & Vegetable Medley

  Stuffed Chicken $24

Twin, All Natural Char-Grilled Chicken Breasts layered with Pulled Pork & Mozzarella, Housemade Caribbean BBQ Sauce

  *Island Churrasco *Island Churrasco is a Gluten-Free Item$37

10oz-CAB ®, Open Flame Grilled, Tomatillo Chimichurri, Red Skin Cheddar, Smashed & Vegetable Medley

  Captain Morgan Ribs $28

Full Rack Baby Rack Ribs roasted with Housemade Captain Morgan Spiced Rum BBQ Sauce, Beer Battered Potato Curls & Cole Slaw

  CUBAN OSSO BUCO $28

24oz Crispy Fried Bone-In Pork Shank, Pickled Onions, Red Skin Cheddar Smashed

Al Dente Keyribbean Style
PASTA

  SEAFOOD DI'AVOLO $28

Jumbo Shrimp, North Atlantic Scallops, Clams, Mussels, Our House Spiced Marinara & Linguini Pasta

  Island Pasta $35

North Atlantic Scallops & Jumbo Shrimp, Cajun Ginger Cream Sauce & Linguini Pasta

  Keyribbean Linguini $27

Chargrilled Chicken Breast & Jumbo Shrimp, Key Lime-Caper-Garlic-Butter Sauce & Linguini Pasta

  SEAFOOD CANNELLONI $25

Rolled & Stuffed Pasta, Lobster Meat, Lump Crab,, Scallops, Ricotta-Jack-Cheddar Cheese Blend, Homemade Smoky Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella

SIDES

Cole Slaw $3

Red Skin Cheddar Smashed $5

Island Rice $4

French Fries $5

Side Caesar $5

Veggies $5

Chips & Pico $6

House Salad $5

Gluten-Free

Certified Angus Beef Logo

* Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, shellfish or eggs may increase your riskof foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions *

CAB ® is the exclusive trademark of Certified Angus Beef LLC

When using multiple credit cards, please let your server know before ordering